We teach our daughters to recognize their worth. But are our communal expectations telling them something different?
I returned from the recent Torah Umesorah Convention feeling both inspired and troubled.
Inspired by the extraordinary dedication of our mechanchim and Rabbanim to strengthening our children's chinuch. At the Atzmi booth, girls and educators shared how meaningful our My Best Self curriculum had been. These conversations were incredibly gratifying.
But other conversations left me with a question I haven't been able to stop thinking about.
Are we so focused on what we're teaching our children that we're overlooking the expectations we're placing upon them?
When Five Pounds Determine Your Future
A shadchan from Lakewood described the challenges young women face when they don't meet increasingly narrow expectations around body size. She spoke about accomplished, kind, intelligent young women, committed to Torah and chesed, who struggle even to be offered shidduch dates because they aren't sufficiently thin.
Then I heard about a shadchan who reportedly refuses to work with young women weighing more than 120 pounds. 120 pounds. That is her hard cutoff.
A young woman pursuing a degree in nursing, wearing a size six and weighing 125 pounds, reportedly cannot even be considered for a date through this shadchan.
Five pounds.
Not her middos. Not her intelligence, kindness, or values. Not her compatibility with a potential spouse.
A number on a scale.
The possibility that such arbitrary criteria are determining who deserves an introduction should alarm us. Of course, attraction matters. But attraction is not a universal weight limit.
We are not simply trying to arrange weddings. We are trying to build Jewish homes.
When Changing the Young Woman Becomes the Solution
Another troubling secondhand account, shared through a source I consider reliable, concerned a Rav who reportedly recommended cosmetic procedures or weight-loss medication, even before young women begin dating, to avoid future shidduch rejections. I cannot independently verify the precise advice or its circumstances.
I recognize that such recommendations may come from a sincere desire to help young women find their zivugim. But why is the proposed solution to change the young woman rather than challenge the expectations?
Today it's weight-loss medications, cosmetic surgery, nose jobs, and lip fillers. Where does it end?
We teach our daughters that their worth comes from their neshama, their middos, their relationship with Hashem, and the unique gifts He has given them.
Yet what happens when they enter shidduchim and discover that these qualities may not even be considered unless their appearance meets someone else's expectations?
How can we expect young women to believe what we're teaching them when our actions communicate something entirely different?
And what about our Rabbanim and Rebbeim? Aren't they precisely the people we look to for guidance in ensuring that our priorities reflect Torah values?
And where is Hashem in this process?
We know that Hashem is intimately involved in bringing two people together. We do our hishtadlus, but the outcome is ultimately in His hands.
When did appropriate hishtadlus become synonymous with changing the bodies Hashem gave us to satisfy arbitrary beauty standards?
And What Happens When Our Daughters Look Like Us?
There is another consequence we rarely consider.
We can use medication to change our body size or undergo surgery to alter our appearance. But these interventions don't change the genetic traits and predispositions we may pass on to our children.
What happens when a woman looks at her daughter and sees the very nose she felt pressured to change? Or when her daughter develops the body type she spent years believing was unacceptable?
Will she see the beautiful, unique child Hashem entrusted to her, or will she feel compelled to help her daughter change, too?
This isn't to suggest that a mother who struggles with her appearance cannot love her daughter unconditionally. But the beliefs we internalize about our bodies can influence the messages we pass on, often without realizing it.
We can change how our bodies look without changing the beliefs that taught us to dislike them.
And unless we address those beliefs, we risk passing them on to the next generation.
When Appearance Comes Before Health
The consequences may extend far beyond the shidduch process. And the pressure to change our bodies isn't always explicit.
In a recent Yated Ne'eman column, a woman in her thirties described how she had never been particularly concerned about her weight. But as more people around her began taking weight-loss medications and losing significant amounts of weight, she started feeling that she was falling behind.
Her question was telling: How do we distinguish between making a choice for ourselves and making one because everyone around us seems to be doing it?
This is how cultural expectations take hold. What begins as an individual choice can gradually become a communal expectation. Before long, women who were once comfortable with their bodies may feel compelled to change them simply to keep up.
Of course, GLP-1 medications have legitimate medical uses and can provide meaningful benefits when appropriately prescribed. But every medical decision requires a thoughtful assessment of potential benefits, risks, and alternatives. The pressure to conform should never substitute for that evaluation.
Perhaps one of the most important questions we need to ask isn't simply whether we can change our bodies, but why we feel we must.
And the potential consequences deserve serious attention.
A pharmacist shared concerns about young women pursuing extreme thinness, some reportedly experiencing menstrual irregularities and fertility-related difficulties. These accounts do not establish that the medications caused those problems, but inadequate nutrition and excessive weight loss can disrupt reproductive function.
Think about the irony. We place tremendous importance on helping young women marry and build families, yet the pressures surrounding that very goal may be compromising their health.
And then came another account that left me stunned.
I was told about a New York pediatrician concerned about premature births, low birth weights, and babies struggling to thrive. The concern relayed to me was that some expectant mothers may not be nourishing themselves adequately because they are determined to be thin enough to wear a belt at their baby's bris.
A belt. At the bris.
I cannot independently verify these cases or establish that the reported medical outcomes are due to maternal restriction. But inadequate nutrition during pregnancy can pose serious risks.
Have we become so focused on how a mother looks at her baby's bris that we're losing sight of the health of the mother and baby?
Surely this should give us pause.
We Must Engage Our Young Men, Too
At Atzmi, we work to strengthen self-worth, resilience, and healthy body image through Torah-aligned, evidence-based prevention education.
But I've become increasingly convinced that we must broaden this conversation to include our young men.
We spend years teaching young women to recognize their worth. We must be equally intentional about helping young men recognize and appreciate those qualities in a potential spouse.
What are we teaching our young men about beauty, attraction, character, and marriage? What messages are parents communicating about the kind of young woman their sons should marry? And what responsibility do shadchanim, Rebbeim, and Rabbanim have in shaping these expectations?
We are working so hard to raise young women who know their worth. Are we equally committed to raising young men who know how to recognize it?
This isn't about dismissing attraction or blaming young men. It's about ensuring that our expectations reflect the values we hold dear.
What Do We Need to Change?
There is reason for hope. Recently, I was invited to speak with a Vaad Harabonim about eating disorders and the challenges families are facing. Their thoughtful questions and genuine desire to help were deeply encouraging.
Our community has extraordinary educators, dedicated leaders, and a tremendous commitment to the well-being of our children.
But meaningful change requires us to look beyond what we're teaching in our classrooms.
We must examine what we praise, what we normalize, and what our expectations communicate.
We cannot teach our daughters that their worth is not determined by their appearance and body size while allowing the systems around them to communicate otherwise.
Perhaps the next step in strengthening our children's chinuch isn't simply asking what more we need to teach them. It's asking what we, as adults, need to change.
Because ultimately, the question is not simply whether our daughters believe they are worthy.
It's whether we are building a community that treats them as though they are.